Download / print this Cast (PDF)
Sibley Lake
Mon Nov 16 – Wed Nov 18, 2026 · Mountain Time · Trout
- Shallow cover, points, creek mouths
- First light (7:07 AM MST) → ~9 AM
- Use any ripple as cover
- Shade lines, docks, deeper edges
- Electronics for bait height first
- Slow down once the sun is overhead
- Revisit shallow shade as sun drops
- Topwater if the surface lays down
- Weekday traffic is lighter — work quiet pockets
Fall Transition Trout plan: Target inflows and shoreline drop-offs as water cools; spoons, spinners and streamers, moderate.
Trout are in the fall transition — following bait into creeks and onto flats as water cools.
Basis: estimated water ~48°F — 75-day observed air record (NOAA ACIS) lagged for a lake (14-day response); no water-temperature gauge on the lake; air record trending rising
What's on the menu: aquatic insects, scuds and leeches.
Brook trout. Fall brookies are bright and aggressive near shore; a small spinner or streamer draws strikes.
Weekday traffic — lighter than the weekend. Fish early, give ramps and swim areas room.
Fixed Dam-controlled water. No shared generation/level feed this cycle — check the agency page the morning you fish; releases and pool levels change daily. Stay outside buoyed restricted zones.
| Item | Note | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Permit / regs | Check current Wyoming Game and Fish regulations before you keep any fish. | |
| Clarity | The calm, sunny days make for clear water and spooky fish, so long casts and light line help. | |
Fish from the accessible fishing dock or the shoreline around the Sibley Lake recreation area. Cast a small spinner or spoon along drop-offs, or fish a worm or floating bait off the bottom near the dock. Fly anglers can strip a small leech pattern or float a dry fly during calm evenings.
Sibley Lake is a great water for kayaks, canoes and float tubes, since only non-motorized craft are allowed. Launch at the recreation area boat ramp and paddle-troll a small spoon, spinner or wooly bugger slowly along the shoreline and drop-offs.
Gas motors aren't allowed on Sibley Lake, so bring a canoe, small rowboat or other non-motorized craft. Launch at the boat ramp in the Sibley Lake recreation area.
Dry fly or small dry-dropper rig on calm mornings when fish rise. Bobber and worm along shallow flats at first light. Surface action fades quickly once the wind builds.
Small spoon in gold, silver or orange cast along drop-offs. Inline spinner retrieved slowly near the windward bank. Wooly bugger or leech pattern trolled from a kayak.
Floating bait or worm on a slip-sinker rig from shore. Worm harness behind a flasher, trolled deeper at midday. Small jig tipped with a worm near the bottom.